51ÁÔÆæ

The transitional measure under the new parental leave scheme grants an additional 10 weeks of SLWFP to staff members who were already on maternity leave on 1 January 2023. This measure was created to facilitate the transition from the previous parental leave scheme to the new one, and to enable equity and fairness in the treatment of staff members who became parents by giving birth. The Applicant, however, had exhausted her maternity leave entitlements and was instead on annual leave on 1 January 2023.

The Tribunal found no merit in her argument that she should be considered as still on...

The transitional measure under the new parental leave scheme grants an additional 10 weeks of special leave with full pay ("SLWFP") to staff members who were already on maternity leave on 1 January 2023. This measure was created to facilitate the transition from the previous parental leave scheme to the new one, and to enable equity and fairness in the treatment of staff members who became parents by giving birth.

The Tribunal found that the transitional measure was a fair, reasonable, and rational solution. Under it, all birthing parents that were still on maternity leave when the new policy...

Le Tribunal a rappel¨¦ qu'il n'est pas comp¨¦tent pour examiner les requ¨ºtes ¨¦manant de personnes qui ne sont pas membres du personnel.

Le Tribunal a estim¨¦ que la requ¨ºte n'¨¦tait pas recevable ratione personae parce qu'¨¤ la date d'introduction de la pr¨¦sente requ¨ºte, le requ¨¦rant n'¨¦tait pas membre du personnel des Nations Unies et que la d¨¦cision contest¨¦e n'avait aucune incidence sur le statut du requ¨¦rant en tant qu'ancien membre du personnel ou ne violait pas les termes de son ancienne nomination ou de son ancien contrat d'emploi.

Dans ces circonstances et compte tenu du fait que la requ¨ºte n...

The Tribunal recalled that it lacks jurisdiction to consider applications from non-staff members.

The Tribunal found that the application was not receivable ratione personae because at the date of the filing of the present application, the Applicant was not a staff member of the United Nations and the contested decision had no bearing on the Applicant¡¯s status as a former staff member or otherwise breached the terms of his former appointment or contract of employment.

Under the circumstances and considering that the application was not receivable, there was no need for the Tribunal to examine...

Demande d'anonymisation du requ¨¦rant

Le Tribunal a estim¨¦ que la pr¨¦sente affaire n'est pas comparable ¨¤ l'affaire AAE 2023-UNAT-1332 car le requ¨¦rant ne fait r¨¦f¨¦rence qu'au ? pr¨¦judice que cette affaire lui a caus¨¦ ? et aux ? informations sensibles ? mentionn¨¦es dans l'affaire sans fournir d'autres raisons pour lesquelles le Tribunal s'¨¦carterait des principes de transparence et d'obligation de rendre compte. Par cons¨¦quent, la requ¨ºte du requ¨¦rant a ¨¦t¨¦ rejet¨¦e.

¸é±ð³¦±ð±¹²¹²ú¾±±ô¾±³Ù¨¦

Le Tribunal a pr¨¦cis¨¦ que la r¨¦affectation du requ¨¦rant ¨¤ un poste correspondant ¨¤ son nouveau niveau P-5 apr¨¨s sa...

Applicant¡¯s request for anonymization

The Tribunal found that the instant case is not comparable to AAE 2023-UNAT-1332 as the Applicant only refers to the¡°harm this case has caused¡± him and the ¡°sensitive information¡± referred to in the case without providing further reasons for the Tribunal to deviate from the principles of transparency and accountability. Therefore, the Applicant¡¯s motion was denied.

Receivability

The Tribunal clarified that the Applicant's reassignment to a post reflecting his new P-5 level after demotion is a separate administrative decision for which the Applicant did not...

¸é±ð³¦±ð±¹²¹²ú¾±±ô¾±³Ù¨¦
Le d¨¦fendeur a contest¨¦ la recevabilit¨¦ de la requ¨ºte. Toutefois, le Tribunal l'a jug¨¦e recevable car il a consid¨¦r¨¦ que la requ¨¦rante contestait la d¨¦cision de ne pas ouvrir d'enqu¨ºte sur sa plainte pour conduite potentiellement interdite, et non le r¨¦sultat de l'¨¦valuation de la gestion comme le soutenait le d¨¦fendeur.
µþ¾±±ð²Ô-´Ú´Ç²Ô»å¨¦
Le Tribunal a rappel¨¦ qu'il n'est pas mandat¨¦ pour mener une nouvelle enqu¨ºte sur l'affaire, ni pour tirer ses propres conclusions des ¨¦l¨¦ments de preuve. Il est plut?t charg¨¦ de d¨¦terminer si l'¨¦valuation pr¨¦liminaire a ¨¦t¨¦ men¨¦e correctement sur la base...

Receivability

The Respondent challenged the receivability of the application. However, the Tribunal found it receivable as it considered that the Applicant challenged the decision not to initiate an investigation into her complaint of potential prohibited conduct, and not the outcome of the management evaluation as argued by the Respondent.

Merits

The Tribunal recalled that it is not mandated to conduct a fresh investigation in the matter, nor to draw its own conclusions of the evidence. Instead, it is tasked with identifying whether the preliminary assessment was conducted properly based on the...

Les d¨¦clarations verbales g¨¦n¨¦rales, qui, selon le requ¨¦rant, ont ¨¦t¨¦ faites par son premier notateur lors de r¨¦unions d¡¯¨¦quipe, ne peuvent constituer une promesse expresse de renouvellement de son TA. Plus important encore, ces d¨¦clarations verbales ne contenaient pas les ¨¦l¨¦ments essentiels d¡¯une offre de renouvellement appropri¨¦e et concr¨¨te, tels que la dur¨¦e de la prolongation et le nom de la personne nomm¨¦e. En outre, le Tribunal a conclu qu¡¯aucun engagement officiel n¡¯avait ¨¦t¨¦ pris par ¨¦crit envers le requ¨¦rant pour justifier une attente de renouvellement de son TA.

Le Tribunal a...

General verbal statements, which the Applicant asserts were made by his Fist Reporting Officer during team meetings, cannot constitute an express promise to renew his TA. More importantly, such verbal statements lacked the essential elements of a proper and concrete offer of renewal, such as the duration of the extension and the name of the appointee. Furthermore, the Tribunal found that no official commitment was made to the Applicant in writing to substantiate an expectation of renewal of his TA.

The Tribunal found that performance management procedures governed by ST/AI/2010/5 and...

Le Tribunal a not¨¦ que les contestations/plaintes du requ¨¦rant ne d¨¦coulaient pas d¡¯une d¨¦cision administrative claire. La premi¨¨re contestation concernait un manquement pr¨¦sum¨¦ de l¡¯administration ¨¤ se conformer pleinement ¨¤ la section 2.4 ST/AI/1998/9 (Syst¨¨me de classification des postes). La seconde ¨¦tait fond¨¦e sur l¡¯hypoth¨¨se apparente du requ¨¦rant selon laquelle il aurait d? ¨ºtre reclass¨¦/promu au niveau GS-7 apr¨¨s la reclassification ¨¤ la hausse du poste qu¡¯il occupait.

En cons¨¦quence, le Tribunal a interpr¨¦t¨¦ la requ¨ºte dans son ensemble pour d¨¦terminer exactement le point de d¨¦part...

The Tribunal noted that the Applicant¡¯s challenges/complaints did not derive from one clear administrative decision. The first challenge was addressed to an alleged failure by the Administration to fully comply with sec. 2.4 ST/AI/1998/9 (System for the classification of posts). The second one was based on the Applicant¡¯s apparent assumption that he should have been upgraded/promoted to GS-7 level after the upward reclassification of the post he was encumbering.

As a result, the Tribunal interpreted the application as a whole to determine exactly the starting point of the Applicant¡¯s...

Apr¨¨s avoir examin¨¦ le dossier, le Tribunal a conclu que le requ¨¦rant n¡¯avait pas contest¨¦ les faits sur lesquels la mesure disciplinaire ¨¦tait fond¨¦e. Il n¡¯a pas contest¨¦ non plus que ses actes constituaient juridiquement une faute ou que ses droits ¨¤ une proc¨¦dure r¨¦guli¨¨re avaient ¨¦t¨¦ respect¨¦s. En cons¨¦quence, la principale question en l¡¯esp¨¨ce ¨¦tait de savoir si la mesure disciplinaire impos¨¦e ¨¦tait proportionn¨¦e ¨¤ l¡¯infraction commise. Cependant, comme la proportionnalit¨¦ de la sanction ne peut ¨ºtre examin¨¦e de mani¨¨re isol¨¦e, le Tribunal a jug¨¦ appropri¨¦ de se r¨¦f¨¦rer aux faits ¨¦tablis...

Having considered the case record, the Tribunal found that the Applicant did not contest the facts upon which the disciplinary measure was based. He did not contest either that his actions legally amounted to misconduct or that his due process rights were observed. Accordingly, the main issue in the present case was whether the disciplinary measure imposed was proportionate to the offense committed. However, as the proportionality of the sanction cannot be reviewed in isolation, the Tribunal deemed it appropriate to refer to the established facts and the misconduct as per the sanction letter.

¸é±ð³¦±ð±¹²¹²ú¾±±ô¾±³Ù¨¦

Le Tribunal a jug¨¦ que dans la mesure o¨´ la requ¨¦rante contestait le cadre juridique du HCR et demandait la suppression d¡¯une partie du paragraphe 34 de la politique de recrutement et d¡¯affectation, sa candidature n¡¯¨¦tait pas recevable ratione materiae. La candidature n¡¯¨¦tait recevable qu¡¯en ce qui concerne la d¨¦cision de ne pas s¨¦lectionner la requ¨¦rante pour le poste G-7 d¡¯associ¨¦ principal en gestion des ressources, charg¨¦ de la lutte contre l¡¯exploitation et les atteintes sexuelles et sexuelles.

Fond

Question de savoir si les proc¨¦dures applicables ont ¨¦t¨¦ correctement...

Receivability

The Tribunal found that to the extent the Applicant challenged the legal framework of UNHCR, and requested the removal of a part of para. 34 of the Recruitment and Assignments Policy, her application was not receivable ratione materiae. The application was only receivable concerning the decision not to select the Applicant for the G-7 position of Senior Resource Management Associate, Addressing SEA and SH.

Merits

Whether the applicable procedures were properly followed

First, the Tribunal addressed the Applicant¡¯s argument concerning the alleged forgery of the document...

Lors de l¡¯examen des d¨¦cisions li¨¦es au rendement, ilLe litige entre les parties porte sur la question de savoir si le requ¨¦rant a rempli la condition de service satisfaisant pendant sa p¨¦riode probatoire pour justifier un droit contractuel ¨¤ ce que son ATF soit converti en ACR. Dans ce contexte, le requ¨¦rant pr¨¦tend que son AFR et son ASR n'ont pas identifi¨¦ de lacunes de rendement pendant le cycle de rendement, y compris lors des deux entretiens ? marquants ? sur le rendement qu'ils ont eus avant la d¨¦cision contest¨¦e. Il semblerait que la premi¨¨re fois qu'il a entendu parler d'une...

The dispute between the parties relates to whether the Applicant met the condition of satisfactory service during his probationary period to warrant a contractual right to have his FTA converted into a CA. In this context, the Applicant claims that his FRO and SRO did not identify any performance shortcomings during the performance cycle, including at the two ¡°landmark¡± performance discussions they had previously to the contested decision. Allegedly, the first time he heard about any dissatisfaction with his performance was when he was informed that he would not receive a CA and, instead...

La principale question soumise ¨¤ l'examen du Tribunal dans cette affaire concernait la l¨¦galit¨¦ de la suppression du poste du requ¨¦rant entra?nant le non-renouvellement de son engagement ¨¤ dur¨¦e d¨¦termin¨¦e.

Le Tribunal a d¨¦fini les questions ¨¤ examiner en l'esp¨¨ce comme suit :

La restructuration ¨¦tait-elle authentique ?

Les ¨¦l¨¦ments de preuve vers¨¦s au dossier montrent que la restructuration a ¨¦t¨¦ effectu¨¦e dans le cadre de la transition ¨¤ l'¨¦chelle du Secr¨¦tariat de l'ONU des services de technologie de l'information et de la communication ("TIC") de l'entreprise vers le nuage. La CESAP a...

The main issue for the Tribunal¡¯s consideration in this case related to whether the abolishment of the Applicant¡¯s post leading to the non-renewal of his fixed-term appointment was lawful.

The Tribunal defined the issues to be examined in the present case as follows:

Whether the restructuring was genuine;
The evidence on record showed that the restructuring was done within the framework of the UN Secretariat-wide transition of Enterprise Information and Communication Technology (¡°ICT¡±) services to the cloud. ESCAP made strategic changes to implement this new approach, leading to the...