¡°Establishing the rule of law is essential to creating lasting peace¡±, Ms. McCall Carter, judicial affairs officer at the United Nations Headquarters
Ms. McCall Carter is a judicial affairs officer at the United Nations Headquarters who previously served in peacekeeping operations in both South Sudan and Liberia as well as at international criminal tribunals.
It¡¯s been proven over time that establishing the rule of law is essential to creating lasting peace, and that is exactly why peacekeeping missions have been mandated to work on these issues. One of Ms. Carter¡¯s achievements while serving in the field was helping establish mobile courts in South Sudan. The local population credited the court¡¯s presence in affected communities with deterring crimes such as rape and other forms of sexual and gender-based violence, murder, robbery and looting.
Question: Please tell us about some of the typical work that a judicial officer could do in a place like South Sudan where there is limited rule of law.
McCall Carter: The functions of a judicial affairs officer could range from presenting on the South Sudanese legal system at trainings for police, to working with parliamentarians to share regional examples and review laws to help ensure they were consistent with international norms. They also support prosecutors, investigators, judges, and prison officials to deploy to remote conflict-affected areas in what we would call mobile courts. It¡¯s been proven over time that establishing the rule of law is essential to creating lasting peace, and that is exactly why peacekeeping missions have been mandated to work on these issues.
Question: Is there an absence of normal courtroom buildings in places like South Sudan?
McCall Carter: There is. South Sudan is the world's newest State - it just celebrated its 15th birthday. It did not have many courts at independence, and the conflicts in 2013 and 2016 also resulted in the destruction of a lot of the courtrooms, police stations and prisons that did exist.
Question: Mobile courts were considered by many people to be a great success of the UN mission in South Sudan. Could you tell me why they were set up and what have they achieved overall?
McCall Carter: Many of them were set up for different reasons, but I'll speak specifically about a joint special mobile court that was set up to adjudicate crimes following a particularly violent cattle migration season between two different states in South Sudan in 2019 and 2020. It was joint because it was between two different states. It was special because it was established under a provision in national law that enabled both traditional and statutory judges to be involved in it, and it was mobile because it moved around. This particular court was established at the request of communities, who were seeking accountability for serious crimes and asked the government, particularly the governors of their respective states, to support that.
In all locations where this court sat, communities requested it to stay longer to hear more cases and attributed enhanced peace and stability to its presence. They credited the court¡¯s presence in affected communities with deterring crimes such as rape and other forms of SGBV, murder, robbery and looting, which were prevalent at the start of the project.
Question: This sounds like a big project to make these courts happen. I'm sure your office did not do this alone, were there other parts of UNMISS or the UN system who helped get this together?
McCall Carter: Yes. It was an all-hands-on-deck effort and a whole-of-mission approach for the mobile courts. Within the Mission, we worked closely with civil affairs colleagues, who had been the ones organizing a lot of the local dialogues that had resulted in the communities¡¯ calls for accountability. They also helped us to understand local dynamics better. Human Rights colleagues had investigated many of the more serious cases, and sought the consent of survivors or victims of violence who might be seeking accountability to share information with national officials. UN Police, along with the international prosecutors, judges and corrections officers working with the Rule of Law section provided day-to-day, hands-on mentoring to the national officials assigned to the court. We engaged the military component at Mission Headquarters to issue the necessary orders for the force to be able to support this work. At the field office level, the military was responsible for providing security for the UN personnel accompanying the courts, including through setting up temporary operating basis. While the force didn't provide security to the national actors - that was the responsibility of the government of South Sudan ¨C their presence and regular patrols helped to stabilize the surrounding area, which was important because there were times when the mobile court heard sensitive cases that involved violent individuals.
Question: I wanted to explore the protection of civilian sites, which we often hear about. When intercommunal violence break out at large scale and you may have the national army and breakaway armies clashing. Where do all these people go? What is a temporary protection site?
McCall Carter: Well, in December 2013 and July 2016 large-scale fighting broke out in South Sudan and individuals were being targeted based on their ethnicity. They fled for their lives and ran to UNMISS, the peacekeeping mission for protection. Once the immediate violence died down, they didn't feel safe to go back. In fact, many of them couldn¡¯t go back - their houses had been destroyed or occupied by other people. What ended up being set up were what came to be known as ¡®POC sites¡¯ - protection of civilian sites. These sites were similar to internally displaced persons camps, except that their location vis-¨¤-vis the UN peacekeeping mission meant that they were deemed extensions of UN premises and were granted the same legal protections ¨C that is, they were inviolable and subject to the exclusive control and authority of the UN. This meant that responsibility for the security of these sites was with the UN and not with the national government. Some of them had a few thousand. Others had over 100,000. At one point , some 224,000 people lived in six POC sites across the country. So, some of them were quite large, the size of cities.
Question: How does the rule of law exist in such a place where the national authorities are not present in there with police and judges and everybody else?
McCall Carter: Well, providing security does not just mean static outside security, but also ensuring public safety. When you have that many people together, there inevitably will be conflict, and crime will occur. Since the UN was responsible for public safety and security in these sites, this meant that individuals who had committed serious crimes were sometimes arrested by the UN police. In the most serious cases, those individuals couldn't just go back, not just because of the gravity of the crimes, but also because there was no formal judicial system that could adjudicate the cases, and the customary courts couldn't legally hear these cases, so they themselves could have been at risk of being killed in retaliatory violence.
And so, the UN ended up having to set up detention facilities, which were run by corrections officers in the Rule of Law section - government-provided personnel who were seconded from other countries to work in the UN Mission in South Sudan. Since the POC Sites weren¡¯t under government control, there wasn't any real connection with the national police, which meant that some people were held in these facilities for quite some time.
When the Rule of Law section was re-established in 2017 in the peacekeeping mission, one of the things we were tasked to do was to begin to make these linkages. And so, there was a lot of work trying to get cases investigated, negotiating with the communities to allow national police to come in to investigate, making sure that investigations were followed up and weren't somehow compromised, so that the community could begin to trust the justice system again. This also meant working with judges. In Juba, there were some judges in the city, so in those cases the Mission took the individuals to the courthouses for their cases to be heard. In other places, where there were no judges, this meant bringing in judges from other places to sit and hear cases in or near the POC Sites themselves. This was actually how the mission began getting involved in mobile courts. Progressively, the security situation got better, trust began to be rebuilt, and the last POC Site was transitioned earlier this year in 2026.
Question: A lot of people when they think of peacekeeping operation, think of military personnel wearing blue helmets and UN police wearing blue berets. But there is a large civilian component, the judicial part is obviously one of those parts. What other kinds of civilian careers could one seek in a UN peacekeeping operation?
McCall Carter: There's a lot of different careers. In addition to the Judicial Affairs Officers (and Corrections Officers, which I mentioned as well), there are human rights officers who investigate, monitor and report on human rights abuses. There are civil affairs officers who, at least in South Sudan, did a lot of the sub-national political work, as well as working with communities to resolve conflict before it turns violent. And there are Political Affairs Officers who analyze the various political dynamics and provide advice to senior mission leadership. And then there's also a lot of mission support jobs in procurement, movement control, and logistics that also are performed by civilians in peacekeeping missions.
Question: Civilians are also involved in strategic communications to help build public support for the work of peacekeeping operations. In South Sudan, they run a radio station with internation and national staff that reaches up to a million people a day. Can you discuss that at all?
McCall Carter: Yes, in South Sudan it's called Radio Miraya, they all have different names. These radio stations have been incredibly impactful, as radio is one of the main ways people get information in most of these places. In South Sudan, Radio Miraya was and still is a place where people are able to discuss important issues; they have call-in shows, and it's really fascinating to listen to and to see the conversations that are happening on air.
Question: Did Miraya go out to the mobile courts to cover that work there?
McCall Carter: Yes, they did. But in addition to Radio Miraya, judges and prosecutors also went on local radio stations to make sure the communities were aware of why they were there. This was important because the first time that the joint special mobile court went out there had been a lot of different misinformation about what what the court was doing. In addition to educating citizens about what they were doing, they also participated in radio shows where citizens could call in and ask them questions - which was a kind of engagement with officials that otherwise citizens never would have had the chance to have.
Question: When you were studying law in the United States, did you ever think that you would have a career where you were dealing with such complex situations in other countries, places where there are no courts, places where you have hundreds of thousands of civilians protected in a site? It must be exciting and fulfilling.
McCall Carter: It was incredibly professionally fulfilling. I actually did get into law because I wanted to do international criminal law, and started in the UN with the international criminal tribunals, so working in post-conflict situations was my intention. But it¡¯s important to realize that those courts may take years to establish; they will only hear a small fraction of the crimes that happen in these conflicts, and they'll only hold the ones most responsible to account. This makes the work of national actors and national courts that peacekeeping missions support all the more important to deliver justice for victims in these situations.
.
